place

Best Seafood in Harlem, NYC: 5 Must-Try Spots for Every Foodie

Globexfeed

— 4 min read

Discover Harlem’s Unforgettable Seafood Scene

Harlem, New York City, is a treasure trove of flavors where the seafood scene tells a story of cultural fusion and community roots. From Caribbean-inspired shacks brimming with spicy crab legs to Southern-style fried fish joints that feel like home, and even upscale sushi spots mastering modern Japanese techniques, Harlem offers something for every seafood lover.Influenced by a blend of Caribbean spices and Southern comfort food traditions, often served in casual, neighborhood settings, this vibrant area invites you to dive into its diverse culinary waters. Let’s explore five top-rated spots that locals and visitors can’t stop raving about!

LoLo's Seafood Shack ⭐ 4.1 / 5

Nestled near the C & D Train Station, LoLo's Seafood Shack is a vibrant Caribbean-inspired spot that’s become a go-to for seafood buckets and crab legs bursting with unique flavors. Its convenient location makes it an easy stop for a quick, tasty meal, and the casual atmosphere with vibrant decor adds to the experience. Local tip: Visit during non-peak hours for quicker service.

"Very nice espec... crab legs" (TripAdvisor)
LoLo's Seafood Shack image 1 LoLo's Seafood Shack image 2 LoLo's Seafood Shack image 3 LoLo's Seafood Shack image 4 LoLo's Seafood Shack image 5 LoLo's Seafood Shack image 6

Famous Fish Market ⭐ 4.5 / 5

A neighborhood favorite, Famous Fish Market is the place to go for crispy fried seafood like whiting, shrimp, and clams at incredibly affordable prices. Perfect for a quick takeout meal, this spot boasts fast service and a simple takeout counter vibe. Local tip: Don’t skip the french fries combo for an extra treat.

"Best fish ever!" (TripAdvisor)

Just be aware that seating is limited, and some find the fish flavor a bit overpowering.

Famous Fish Market image 1 Famous Fish Market image 2 Famous Fish Market image 3 Famous Fish Market image 4 Famous Fish Market image 5 Famous Fish Market image 6

Lighthouse Fish Market ⭐ 4.3 / 5

In the heart of East Harlem, Lighthouse Fish Market serves up soul food-inspired seafood with a focus on quality and community ties. Known for sustainably sourced fish and delicious Southern-style sides, it’s a casual neighborhood spot that also offers catering services. Local tip: Check the daily specials board for unique offerings. With moderate pricing, it’s a great choice for a hearty meal.

Lighthouse Fish Market image 1 Lighthouse Fish Market image 2 Lighthouse Fish Market image 3 Lighthouse Fish Market image 4 Lighthouse Fish Market image 5 Lighthouse Fish Market image 6

A Taste of Seafood ⭐ 4.3 / 5

Since 1992, A Taste of Seafood has been a Harlem staple, serving up golden-fried fish paired with classic Southern sides. This no-frills takeout joint is loved for its consistent quality and quick service, making it ideal for a fast, satisfying bite. Local tip: Order early during weekend rushes to avoid the wait.

"Great fried seafood" (TripAdvisor)

Just be aware that the menu variety is somewhat limited.

A Taste of Seafood image 1 A Taste of Seafood image 2 A Taste of Seafood image 3 A Taste of Seafood image 4 A Taste of Seafood image 5 A Taste of Seafood image 6

Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine ⭐ 4.7 / 5

For an upscale twist on seafood, Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine in Harlem offers premium sushi and creative seafood dishes. With high-quality fish and stunning presentations, including omakase options, it’s a gem for sushi lovers. The modern and intimate atmosphere elevates the dining experience. Local tip: Try the lunch specials for better value. Expect higher prices for this elevated dining.

"Hands down the best sushi in Harlem"

Just be aware that the cost can add up quickly.

Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 1 Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 2 Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 3 Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 4 Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 5 Yuzu Sushi Japanese Cuisine image 6

Ready to Dive into Harlem’s Seafood Delights?

Harlem’s seafood offerings are as diverse as the neighborhood itself, and I hope this guide inspires you to explore these incredible spots. Whether you’re craving fried fish or fresh sushi, there’s a dish waiting to steal your heart. Which one will you try first?

Images courtesy of Google Maps and respective businesses.

Read more