Vintage Shopping in Fountain Square, Indianapolis: Hidden Gems to Explore

Vintage Shopping in Fountain Square, Indianapolis: Hidden Gems to Explore

If you’re on the hunt for unique finds and timeless treasures, vintage shopping in Fountain Square, Indianapolis, is a must. This vibrant neighborhood brims with eclectic stores offering everything from curated 90s tees to rare antiques, all wrapped in a creative community vibe. Let’s dive into the top spots to explore!

Click on the place names below to open their locations in Google Maps.

Place Rating Highlights
Zodiac Vintage ⭐ 4.3/5 Curated 90s tees and luxury vintage in a luxe boutique setting.
Midland Arts & Antiques Market ⭐ 4.6/5 Massive antique mall with 150+ vendors and evening auctions.
The Vogue Theatre ⭐ 4.4/5 Historic venue with a vintage charm, hosting unforgettable events.
Days Gone By Antiques ⭐ 5/5 Eclectic antiques in a historic red-brick cultural landmark.
Nuova Vita Vintage ⭐ 5/5 Quiet luxury with sustainably curated 1970s-2000s pieces.

Zodiac Vintage ⭐ 4.3/5

Curated 90s tees, luxury finds, and Levi’s in a boutique-style space co-owned by Jess Parrotte and Jessica Lykens. This shop offers carefully curated high-quality vintage, an airy, luxe boutique atmosphere, and even light repairs like button fixes on items.

💡 Local Tip: Visit on weekends for the best selection.
🎵 Atmosphere: Airy, boutique-like with a focus on preservation and presentation.
🅿️ Parking: Street parking available nearby.

Items sell quickly — one Indiana jacket sold within hours of being posted.
Zodiac Vintage image 1 Zodiac Vintage image 2 Zodiac Vintage image 3 Zodiac Vintage image 4 Zodiac Vintage image 5 Zodiac Vintage image 6

Midland Arts & Antiques Market ⭐ 4.6/5

Massive antique mall with 150+ vendors offering furniture, vintage clothing, and collectibles. It features high-quality, well-preserved items alongside indoor/outdoor vendors and exciting evening auctions.

💡 Local Tip: Check the auction schedule for unique finds.
🎵 Atmosphere: Enormous, maze-like building with diverse booths.
🅿️ Parking: On-site parking available.

Note: Can be pricier than other spots.

Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 1 Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 2 Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 3 Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 4 Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 5 Midland Arts & Antiques Market image 6

The Vogue Theatre ⭐ 4.4/5

A historic venue in Indianapolis known for its vintage charm and unforgettable events. This iconic spot offers a unique glimpse into the past while hosting a variety of performances.

The Vogue Theatre image 1 The Vogue Theatre image 2 The Vogue Theatre image 3 The Vogue Theatre image 4 The Vogue Theatre image 5 The Vogue Theatre image 6

Days Gone By Antiques ⭐ 5/5

Historic red-brick building filled with eclectic antiques and curiosities. Located in the Fountain Square Cultural District, it specializes in rare and unusual items within a cultural landmark.

💡 Local Tip: Ask staff about hidden gems in the collection.
🎵 Atmosphere: Nostalgic, historic setting.
🅿️ Parking: Nearby street parking.

Zodiac Vintage image 1 Zodiac Vintage image 2 Zodiac Vintage image 3 Zodiac Vintage image 4 Zodiac Vintage image 5 Zodiac Vintage image 6

Nuova Vita Vintage ⭐ 5/5

Quiet luxury-focused shop with curated clothing, jewelry, and home goods. It emphasizes sustainable, intentional curation with a focus on pieces from the 1970s to 2000s.

💡 Local Tip: Follow their Instagram for pop-up announcements.
🎵 Atmosphere: Minimalist, gallery-like space.
🅿️ Parking: Parking garage available at The Stutz.

Note: Located within 2 miles of Fountain Square, Indianapolis, IN.

Days Gone By Antiques image 1 Days Gone By Antiques image 2 Days Gone By Antiques image 3 Days Gone By Antiques image 4 Days Gone By Antiques image 5 Days Gone By Antiques image 6

Discover Your Next Treasure in Fountain Square

Ready to uncover hidden gems? Head to Fountain Square, Indianapolis, and explore these vintage havens. Whether it’s a rare antique or a 90s throwback, there’s something waiting just for you!

Images courtesy of Google Maps and respective businesses.

Read more